Warning! This article contains Five Nights at Freddy’s spoilers.Five Nights at Freddy’sdistinguishes itself by choosing a clear direction in the often hazy world of video game movie adaptations. The film, a rendition of the iconic horror game, unleashed an unexpected twist that has caught audiences off-guard and sent ripples through its devoted fanbase. Emma Tammi, holding the dual roles of co-writer and director, provided insights into the movie’s twist and teases what’s next for sequels.

The horror saga, jointly scripted by Tammi, Scott Cawthon (the game’s original creator), and Seth Cuddeback, pivots around Mike Schmidt, portrayed by Josh Hutcherson. As Mike settles into his new role as a security guard at Freddy’s Fazbear Pizza, he quickly realizes the animatronics housed within are not ordinary machines. Initially believed to be merely possessed by the spirits of deceased children, the plot thickens with the unveiling of a mastermind controller: William Afton, the founder of the restaurant,played with chilling finesse by Matthew Lillard.

Freddy Fazbear in the Five Nights at Freddy’s movie with a microphone and top hat.

Post-release, Tammi sat down withTheWrapfor an in-depth discussion about the movie’s final revelations. When probed about the choice of Lillard for the role, she emphasized the joint passion both she and Lillard held for the dark depths of Afton’s character. Tammi remarked,

“Well, he plays two characters in the film, actually, not just one. That was an element that we added for the movie. But in terms of stepping into the shoes of Afton, like Matthew Lillard was so aware of how big those shoes were. And I think you bring someone like him who is so iconic in his own right to the table to step into an iconic character, and it just feels like a match perfectly made.”

Matthew Lillard as Steve Raglan or William Afton sitting at his desk on the phone in Five Nights at Freddy’s.

Five Nights at Freddy’s: How the Horror Movie Compares to the Video Games

Video game to movie adaptations have a reputation for being terrible, so how does the Five Nights at Freddy’s movie compare to its counterpart?

From Quirky Advisor to Sinister Antagonist: Lillard’s Complex Role in Five Nights at Freddy’s Universe

To elaborate further on Lillard’s character, the film introduced him as Steve Raglan, a quirky career advisor who dangles the security job at Freddy’s before Mike. However, as the plot unfolds, officer Vanessa, portrayed by Elizabeth Lail, begins dropping hints about the sinister history of the restaurant owner — only to later be unveiled as Afton’s daughter. The climax crescendos with Afton, donning theinfamous yellow rabbit suit known as Springtrap— a haunting reminder of his previous crimes.

Despite attempts to keep Lillard’s character under wraps, speculations had been rife even before the movie’s premiere. Lillard’s association with theFive Nights at Freddy’sfranchise was somewhat unveiled with early casting news hinting at him taking on the role of Afton. The film, too, didn’t hold back on the foreshadowing. From Raglan’s momentary pause during his first meeting with Mike — a possible recollection of a grim past — to the subtle hints about the owner’s reluctance to part with Freddy’s due to “sentimental reasons.”

Lillard has expressed his dedication to a trilogy in theFive Nights at Freddy’sworld, ahead of the film’s debut. This disclosure further solidified theories regarding his portrayal of the primary antagonist. With the movie wrapping up on the ominous note of Afton trapped in the Springtrap suit, future sequels could explore a gamut of story arcs, ranging from a deep dive into Afton’s dark past to Vanessa and Mike’s relentless pursuit to end Afton’s reign of terror.

Emma Tammi’s adaptation has not only paid homage to the original game but has also reinvigorated it with fresh perspectives and tantalizing revelations. The game is afoot, and we’re all eager spectators.